Frank Fraser Darling: the man who looked beyond the scenery

I stumbled across Frank Fraser Darling while researching my own book, which is not yet published, so watch this space. I first encountered him through Island Years and Island Farm, his account of taking his family to live on Tanera Mòr in the Summer Isles. They occupied part of an abandoned herring station, reclaimed neglected ground and attempted to farm in a place where isolation, poor soil and Atlantic weather were part of everyday life. This was no visiting naturalist observing the landscape from a comfortable distance; Darling placed himself and his family inside the environment he wanted to understand.

He had also lived temporarily on North Rona, a tiny island approximately forty-five miles northwest of Cape Wrath, where he studied grey seals and seabirds. These experiences persuaded him that wildlife, agriculture, landscape and human communities could not be understood separately. During the Second World War, he reclaimed land on Tanera Mòr and advised crofting communities before being appointed to lead the West Highland Survey, an exhaustive investigation into the ecology, economy and social condition of the western Highlands and Islands.

Published in 1955 as West Highland Survey: An Essay in Human Ecology, the resulting book is fascinating, pioneering and, I must confess, rather dry. Its conclusion, however, was explosive. Fraser Darling described the Highlands and Islands as largely 'devastated terrain', arguing that their apparent emptiness and poor productivity were not simply natural. Woodland destruction, repeated burning, overgrazing and generations of damaging land management had helped create the landscape that visitors subsequently admired as untouched wilderness.

Darling believed that repairing the land and improving human life were parts of the same problem. His work did not transform government policy as he hoped, and some of his arguments and solutions have since been challenged, but he was connecting conservation, agriculture and community decades before such thinking became fashionable. He later delivered the BBC Reith Lectures, served on the Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution and received a knighthood. Yet there is remarkably little on the west coast to celebrate the man who lived there, studied it and helped change how we understand it. This article is my modest attempt to begin correcting that omission.

To learn more, listen to the blogcast or book one of our North Coast Explorer private tours.