John William Stewart: the man who came home but changed so little

At Nedd in Assynt, the landscape we admire from the road once offered its inhabitants a rather less agreeable prospect. With little ground fit for cultivation, families depended heavily on fishing after the Clearances, yet had no substantial pier behind which to shelter their boats. John William Stewart left that life for Canada in 1882, and whenever I consider what he achieved there, I can understand the excitement his return must have caused. A fisherman’s son who had gone away in search of opportunity was coming home with a fortune, buying much of the estate on which people like his parents had struggled to make a living.

He had made his name in railway construction, becoming a partner in Foley, Welch and Stewart and helping to drive lines across Canada and the United States. Difficult terrain was hardly unfamiliar to someone raised in Assynt, but Stewart had demonstrated an ability to overcome it on an extraordinary scale, organising the labour, equipment and supplies needed to get railways built. Those skills would eventually take him to the rank of major-general, directing Canadian railway troops behind the Western Front, although when he bought much of Assynt in 1912, his civilian achievements already offered ample grounds for optimism. For communities needing better roads, bridges and water supplies, it is difficult to imagine a new landlord arriving with more useful experience.

People welcomed him with flags at Nedd and Drumbeg, bonfires and speeches, celebrating a Gaelic-speaking local man taking the place of the Sutherland family. What troubles me is how little of the anticipated improvement seems to have followed, given both his understanding of the district and his ability to get things done elsewhere. Reports describe bridges at Elphin and Knockan deteriorating as he withdrew from their maintenance, while residents continued to rely on shallow wells and an inadequate supplementary water supply. He helped with Culag Pier and supported other Highland initiatives, but acknowledging those contributions still leaves the question of why the much larger problems persisted under someone so well equipped to address them.

Reading accounts of Stewart entertaining royalty and members of the Sutherland family in Canada, I find myself returning to the welcome he received at home. Success had brought him comfortably into that influential company, while the people celebrating his arrival in Assynt had hoped, understandably, that some of its benefits would reach them too. We cannot know all his intentions, but I think we can question the distance between what his career proved possible and what his ownership delivered. His journey from Nedd remains remarkable, yet for me its promise fades on his return, because escaping hardship and acquiring an estate proved rather different from changing life for the people still living there.

To learn more, book one of our North Coast Explorer private tours.